Epstein Isn’t a Strategy

While it’s tempting for Democrats to use the Epstein scandal as a political battering ram, doing so risks building a messaging empire on an unstable foundation. The problem isn’t that Epstein isn’t scandalous—it’s that the scandal itself is built on quicksand, not solid bedrock. It’s shrouded in secrecy, riddled with rumors and conspiracy theories, and too easily absorbed into the fog of culture wars, where facts become negotiable and outrage becomes normalized.

To be sure, there’s a real possibility the Epstein revelations could seriously damage Trump and expose the broader moral decay among elites. But there’s also the all-too-familiar risk: that the scandal fades into the long list of Trumpian disgraces that are tolerated, deflected, or forgotten. And in that moment of fading attention, what then? What happens to the deeper structural grievances—the assaults on democracy, economic cruelty, climate sabotage, the migrant concentration camps, the genocide in Gaza, and the slow-motion religious takeover of the American government?

There’s no "Plan B" if Democrats bet it all on Epstein. There’s no sustained path forward to challenge the right-wing extremist machine if the scandal collapses under its own contradictions or gets buried by partisan fatigue. Sure, Epstein may be a moral flashpoint, but it’s a temporary one. Confusing the moment for the movement would be a profound strategic mistake.

And let’s face it: Democrats must tread carefully. Many prominent figures in the Democratic Party have ties to Epstein, and that fact won’t be easily swept under the political rug. If the story explodes, it could just as easily blow back on them.

And in a larger sense, for decades, Democrats have played the same corrupt game as Republicans—bowing to billionaires, voting in line with lobbyist demands, and, most tragically, outright ignoring the needs of their constituents. That’s not a winning moral high ground; it’s a credibility gap. And Americans see right through it.

If Democrats truly want to confront the authoritarian rot at the heart of today’s Republican Party, they must first put their own house in order. They must commit to listening to their constituents. They must anchor their political strategy in moral clarity. They must engage in systemic critique. And they must propose forward-looking solutions that address the needs of everyday Americans, not the billionaires. Pinning their hopes on a flimsy scandal is the lazy way, and if it produces any results at all, it will quickly fade in the next election cycle.

Let’s be clear about this inconvenient fact: there are no shortcuts in conducting the business of democracy. Democracy is hard work. It’s thankless work. It demands great personal sacrifice. But it must be done if we are to continue living in a free and democratic nation.

So yes, pursue Epstein. Expose the networks of abuse. Bring justice to the victims. God knows they’ve waited too long for that day. But don’t lose sight of the bigger fight. Because while it might feel good to pin a scandal on Trump, it won’t win the future. If Democrats aren’t careful, they’ll win this battle, and then they’ll lose the war.

For more great progressive stories, check out The Swarm!